Project gone awry

I saw a similar project here, and figured it wouldn't be too difficult to replicate. In theory it wasn't, but in actuality it was. An "S" is a lot harder to wrap than a "T", let me tell you. I eventually figured out a way to do it so it still looked nice.

It wasn't till I was looking at the picture on my computer that I noticed something off. Anyone else see it? I truly didn't realize it till then, either. Not while I was working on it, not while I was taking a picture...

Anyway, the other side looks like this:
not nearly as nice and even, and it looks a lot worse in person.

So I have to decide if I want to rip it all off and do the curves all over, or what. How motivated am I?